COMPETITION IN EDUCATION
It is not surprising that education and competition are intimately related.
On one hand, it is natural for children to compete and, therefore,
understandable that competition is put to educational use.
On the other hand, competition may be found so important in adult life,
that a society especially educates their young to compete.
For instance, in Sparta,
the most prosperous Greek city in the 8th and 7th centuries BC,
physical education was dominated by contests,
in particular the Olympic Games,
where Spartans often won more than half of the top honors
Marcus Verrius Flaccus, a Roman teacher famous in the late 1st century BC , is credited to have introduced the principal of competition among his student as a pedagogical aid.
He awarded attractive books as prizes.
The Italian scholar Battista Guarino (1434--1513) writes in his account
of proper educational techniques, De ordine docendi et studendi,
that teachers should refrain from physically punishing pupils,
and that students are stimulated by competition , which can be intensified by pairing them off.
Education theorists do not agree on whether competitive desires
should be encouraged or constrained.
One theory claims that, since competition is part of every culture
and since education should transmit culture, it is necessary to incorporate
competition into education to help children get used to it in later life.
Another theory views competition as opposed to collaboration and,
therefore, as an evil element in culture that should be curtailed.
At school this often results in an ambiguous attitude towards competition,
which confuses students,
who will then try to compete successfully without making it appear they compete.
It may help to distinguish two views of competition.
In one view ,
all other competitors are perceived as the focus of competition;
they need to be defeated.
In the second view ,
the focus is oneself or some external entity
(such as the clock or a mathematical problem).
The latter view is more conducive to teamwork,
which has become even more important in modern society .
No comments:
Post a Comment